The Wild Truth About ‘Jersey Shore’ Star Ronnie Ortiz-Magro’s Black Eye!

This is too hard to keep up with…

Last week, Ronnie Ortiz-Magro shared visual evidence that he sustained a black eye at some point, strongly implying baby momma Jen Harley was to blame for the incident in which police were called to break things up.

Related: Ronnie Is Trying To Be A Better Father…

Well, even after allegedly begging for Jen to return to him after the apparent physical altercation, we can now report at least one thing: the black eye Ronnie suffered is from a DIFFERENT incident than the one where cops showed up last week.

Seriously?!

According to TMZ, the black eye came not from the couple’s domestic incident in Vegas a week ago, but rather during a domestic dispute on October 5 back in New Jersey.

During that incident, Jen allegedly punched Ronnie and hit him in the face with her phone.

The Jersey Shore star posted a pic to Instagram (below), but at the time didn’t disclose what was going on, nor did he file a police report:

Ronnie Ortiz Magro Jen Harley Black eye

Now, Vegas police have told him that he’ll need to file a police report back in New Jersey if he wishes to follow up on the alleged abuse incident.

He has not yet done so.

This past weekend, at least, the couple appeared to be back on good terms while boating with friends and celebrating Halloween together, so who the hell knows what’s going on…

Thoughts, Perezcious readers?!

Let us know in the comments (below)…

[Images via Instagram.]

The post The Wild Truth About ‘Jersey Shore’ Star Ronnie Ortiz-Magro’s Black Eye! appeared first on Perez Hilton.